Conspiracy theorists? No: the Grenfell survivors are right to distrust the state : Guardian.

Privileged, protected people dare to sneer at the cynicism of betrayed, marginalised group – just as they did at the Hillsborough protesters

  • Eve Livingston is a freelance writer and activist
Local residents protest against outside a meeting about the fire at Kensington Town Hall on Thursday 29 June.
Local residents protest against outside a meeting about the fire at Kensington Town Hall on Thursday 29 June. Photograph: Emerson Utracik/REX/Shutterstock

Perhaps it’s because it has come to represent so much of what is broken in our society that it doesn’t seem possible the Grenfell Tower fire started less than three weeks ago. In the days that have followed, our deepest divisions have played out on the streets of Kensington and beyond: rich versus poor, voiceless versus powerful, those the state protects versus those who pay its price.

And, amidst it all, growing accusations of a cover-up around a death toll that has crept up cautiously and incrementally jar against accounts of flats filled with guests breaking Ramadan fasts, and the frantic mental arithmetic employed to tot up the tower’s likely occupants at 1am on a Wednesday morning.

The reasons for this, and the Metropolitan police’s most recent announcement that the final death toll will probably not be known this year, are many and undoubtedly legitimate. But these things have evoked justifiable anger from residents, as noted by the Labour MP for Tottenham, David Lammy, who tweeted last week that “trust is at rock bottom in the community. Failure to provide updates of the true number that died is feeding suspicion of a cover-up.”

As quickly as they had embraced survivors as passive receptacles for sympathetic platitudes, some corners of the political class took on an increasingly sneering tone as heartbreak turned to anger, and confusion to suspicion. Contempt for an angry working class returned, wrapped up in incredulity that people whose neighbours had burned to death in their homes might harbour some distrust for the state that was meant to protect them.

The idea of a “conspiracy theory” is a disparaging one, evoking images of wild-eyed outcasts rambling incoherently while polite society avoids eye contact. Nasa faked the moon landings, they might say, or Elvis Presley is still alive and wandering brazenly around Graceland; JFK’s murder is unsolved; UFOs crashed in New Mexico; Bush did 9/11.

Read More : The Guardian.

Advertisements

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s