THE SNP’s latest attempt to legalise state snooping on families is “doomed to disaster”, according to a leading human rights lawyer.
In particular, the judges said widespread sharing of family data on the basis of concerns about a child’s wellbeing was not compatible with data protection and European human rights laws.
The planned reforms will instead put the onus onto teachers, NHS staff and social workers to decide whether data sharing would be legal in each case.
That is grossly irresponsible, and doomed to disaster, if those officials – and the Scottish Parliament – are looking to exactly the same people as didn’t appreciate in the first place that they were getting it wrong, and think that the Supreme Court
Allan Norman, who specialises in this area, said: “We have new draft legislation that says, roughly, that officials should share information, provided it is consistent with human rights and data protection laws to do so. True. But I’m afraid that simply shifts the risk to the officials who have to work out what the law means.